U.S. employers added just 29,000 jobs in September, according to data released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics and reported across outlets including CBS News, NPR, Reuters, Fox Business, Just the News and The Washington Times. The unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2%, multiple outlets reported, with CNBC noting the rate had been expected to hold at 4.1%.
The figure fell well short of economist forecasts, which outlets cited at different levels: The Guardian reported expectations of just under 70,000 new jobs, The Independent said the total undershot expectations by 60,000 jobs, CNBC cited a forecast of 84,000, and both The Times of India and The American Conservative cited a forecast of 90,000.
Job gains for prior months were revised downward. NPR and Forbes reported that July and August figures were revised down by a combined 60,000 jobs, with Forbes specifying that July's number was revised to a loss of 10,000 jobs. The Hill reported, citing BLS data, that the economy had added 162,000 jobs in August and 31,000 and 21,000 jobs in June and July, respectively, though these figures reflect earlier, since-revised estimates. The Daily Caller similarly reported that previous gains were revised down alongside the cooler-than-expected September number.
The report arrived as the final jobs reading before the midterm elections, according to The Guardian, and Hot Air likewise framed the release as a
midterm miss. Reuters reported that the soft report sent markets higher, while Semafor and the New York Post both reported that the data adds to expectations the Federal Reserve will hold interest rates steady at its upcoming meeting.
Some outlets highlighted sector-specific details not covered elsewhere. RedState reported that manufacturing and construction added jobs in the new report. Deadline reported that employment in movies and music dipped by about 200 jobs to 328,500, while employment among broadcasting and content providers fell by 3,000 to 328,100. The Washington Examiner reported that, despite the headline disappointment, details within the report suggested the underlying health of commerce was better than it appeared at first glance. The Times of India reported, according to its own characterization, that workers are growing increasingly anxious, a description not corroborated by other outlets in the supplied material.
How the coverage differed
Left-leaning outlets, including Common Dreams, The Guardian and PBS NewsHour, emphasized the weakness of the report and its political timing, with Common Dreams framing it against
the Trump economy,
and The Guardian noting it was the final jobs report before the midterm election. NPR and USA Today focused on the unemployment rate rising alongside the downward revisions to prior months.
Center outlets, such as CNBC, Axios, UPI and The Hill, concentrated on the raw numbers and the gap versus forecasts, with CNBC and The Times of India specifically citing expectations of 84,000 and 90,000 jobs respectively. Deadline was alone in reporting the entertainment-industry employment breakdown, and Reuters was the only outlet to report the market reaction, noting stocks rose on the soft data. Semafor connected the report directly to the Federal Reserve's October meeting, a link also drawn by the New York Post on the right.
Right-leaning outlets varied in emphasis: RedState highlighted gains in manufacturing and construction that other outlets did not mention, while the Washington Examiner argued the details of the report were
more encouraging,
than the headline figure suggested. Hot Air and The Epoch Times tied the report to midterm politics, with The Epoch Times also noting that Trump urged Oklahoma Republicans to turn out for the midterms. The Daily Caller and Just the News stuck closely to the topline figures without additional framing.
What is still unclear
The sources do not reconcile the differing economist forecast figures cited — ranging from just under 70,000 to 90,000 expected jobs — leaving unclear which projection was most widely used. It also remains unclear how the Washington Examiner's characterization of underlying economic strength squares with the broader downward revisions and rising unemployment rate reported elsewhere.
How each side covered it
Left
- Led with the size of the miss, framing it as a 'teetering' or disappointing economy tied to the Trump administration.
- The Guardian noted this was the final jobs report before the midterm elections.
- NPR and The Guardian emphasized the unemployment rate rising to 4.2% and large downward revisions to prior months.
- Common Dreams highlighted wage growth hitting a five-year low, a detail not corroborated elsewhere in the supplied material.
“US added just 29,000 jobs in September in sharp drop from last month’s gains” — The Guardian
Center
- Reported the 29,000 jobs figure and 4.2% unemployment rate largely without added framing.
- Forbes and The Hill detailed the scale of downward revisions to July and August figures.
- Semafor and Reuters connected the report to market reactions and expectations the Fed will hold rates steady.
- Deadline reported sector-specific job losses in movies, music and broadcasting.
“Labor market faltered in September as jobs increased by just 29,000, unemployment rate rose to 4.2%” — CNBC
Right
- Reported the same 29,000 jobs and 4.2% unemployment figures as other outlets.
- RedState and the Washington Examiner highlighted more encouraging details within the report, such as manufacturing and construction gains.
- The New York Post linked the report to expectations the Fed will hold rates steady.
- The Epoch Times paired the jobs report with news of Trump urging Oklahoma Republicans to turn out for the midterms.
“The details of September’s jobs report are more encouraging” — Washington Examiner
Questions readers ask
How many jobs did the U.S. economy add in September?
The U.S. economy added 29,000 jobs in September, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, as reported by outlets including CBS News, NPR, Reuters and Fox Business.
What is the current U.S. unemployment rate?
The unemployment rate rose to 4.2% in September, up from 4.1%, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics data cited by multiple outlets.
Why did the September jobs report fall short of expectations?
Economists had forecast job growth ranging from just under 70,000 to 90,000, depending on the outlet cited, making the actual 29,000 figure well below projections; outlets did not supply a specific reason for the shortfall.
How does this jobs report affect the Federal Reserve's next move?
Semafor and the New York Post reported that the weak jobs data adds to expectations the Federal Reserve will hold interest rates steady at its upcoming October meeting.
Were previous months' job figures revised?
Yes. NPR and Forbes reported that July and August job gains were revised down by a combined 60,000 jobs, with Forbes reporting July's figure was revised to a loss of 10,000 jobs.
Sources · 41 outlet reports
- Al Jazeera EnglishLeft-leaningUS job growth slows as unemployment rises before midterm elections
- BloombergLeft-leaningUS Firms Add Just 29,000 Jobs, Unemployment Rate Ticks Up
- CBS NewsLeft-leaningEmployers added 29,000 jobs in September, missing economic forecasts
- Common DreamsLeft-leaningUS Added Just 29,000 Jobs, Wage Growth Hit New 5-Year Low Last Month as Trump Economy Teeters
- NBC NewsLeft-leaningLabor market slowed in September, final monthly jobs report before midterms shows
- NPRLeft-leaningThe U.S. added only 29,000 jobs in September as job market lacks spark
- PBS NewsHourLeft-leaningDisappointing 29,000 jobs added in September as unemployment ticks up
- The GuardianLeft-leaningUS added just 29,000 jobs in September in sharp drop from last month’s gains
- The IndependentLeft-leaningUS jobs growth undershoots expectations with 60,000 fewer jobs added than expected
- The New York TimesLeft-leaningU.S. Labor Market Shifts to a Lower Gear
- The Washington PostLeft-leaningU.S. economy added 29,000 jobs in September, signaling a slower labor market
- USA TodayLeft-leaningSeptember jobs report shows slowdown in hiring, unemployment ticks up
- AxiosCenterU.S. adds 29,000 jobs in September, unemployment edges up
- CNACenterUS job growth slows sharply in September; unemployment rate rises to 4.2%
- CNBCCenterU.S. nonfarm payrolls increase by 29,000 in September, less than expected; unemployment rises to 4.2%
- DeadlineCenterU.S. Job Growth Slowed To 29,000 In September, With Slight Dip In Movie And Music Employment
- Financial TimesCenterUS economy adds just 29,000 jobs in September as hiring slows sharply
- ForbesCenterSeptember Jobs Report Shows 29,000 Added—But July Revised To 10,000 Lost
- France 24CenterUS posts weak job growth data in September
- NewsNationCenterJobs report shows 29,000 jobs were added in September
- ReutersCenterUS job growth expected to slow in September; unemployment rate likely steady
- SemaforCenterUS adds 29,000 jobs in September, far short of expectations
- South China Morning PostCenterUS job growth slows sharply in September, unemployment rises
- The HillCenterUS economy added 29,000 jobs in September: BLS
- The Times of IndiaCenter‘Workers growing increasingly anxious’: US adds 29,000 jobs, far below 90,000 expected
- The Wall Street JournalCenterGold Climbs on U.S. Jobs Report Miss
- UPICenterU.S. added 29,000 jobs in September; unemployment up to 4.2%
- BreitbartRight-leaningAmerica Added 29,000 Jobs in September, Unemployment Ticked Up to 4.2%
- Deseret NewsRight-leaningSeptember jobs growth unexpectedly falters, unemployment ticks up
- Fox BusinessRight-leaningUS economy added 29,000 jobs in September, a slower pace than expected
- Hot AirRight-leaningMidterm Miss: US Adds Only 29,000 Jobs in September
- Just the NewsRight-leaningUS economy added 29,000 jobs in September, monthly jobless rate increased to 4.2%: Labor Department
- New York PostRight-leaningJob growth cools in September — sorely missing forecasts as unemployment ticks up
- NewsmaxRight-leaningJob Growth Slows to 29,000, Unemployment Rises to 4.2%
- RedStateRight-leaningManufacturing, Construction Add Jobs in New September Report
- The American ConservativeRight-leaningEconomy Added 29,000 Jobs in September, Short of Projected 90,000
- The Daily CallerRight-leaningJob Numbers Come In Cooler Than Expected As Previous Gains Get Revised Down
- The Epoch TimesRight-leaningUS Economy Adds Just 29,000 Jobs in September, Below Market Estimates
- The Washington TimesRight-leaningU.S. adds only 29,000 jobs in lackluster September report
- TownhallRight-leaningThe September Jobs Report Is Here
- Washington ExaminerRight-leaningEconomy fell short of expectations with 29,000 jobs in September in lackluster report